Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Twilight Zone vs. 1984


The episode “The Eye of the Beholder” of The Twilight Zone shares many striking resemblances to the novel 1984 by George Orwell. The episode begins with an image of a woman named Janet Tyler with bandages on her face. Through the dialogue exchanged between her and the doctor, it is apparent that they are doing experiments on her face. The hospital spends time, money, and treatments to make her as they view “normal”. It can be inferred that ugliness in Tyler’s society is a crime when the doctor says, “You can move into a special area where people of your kind have been congregated”. In the end, it turns out that Tyler is normal looking and everyone else looks like a pig. The message of this episode is that beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

The novel 1984 tells a similar story. Winston is a pariah in Oceania’s society because he sees beyond the superficial. Winston accepts that the Party is deceiving the citizens to try and gain power and, at first, is determined to stop it. The Party finds, tortures, and converts Winston into what they believe is the norm. Similar to Janet Tyler’s scenario, Winston’s possession of seemingly unusual characteristics is considered a crime that must be acknowledged. Also, Oceania has a dictator Big Brother that is seemingly parallel to the man on the television screens in “The Eye of the Beholder”. A major difference between the two stories is the final outcome; the doctors are unsuccessful with Janet Tyler but the Party is successful with Winston. Both stories, however, show that it is only possible to prove something to oneself.

2 comments:

Mrs. Recine said...

Excellent analysis & parallel between the two stories!

Kristina said...

I agree with all the parallelisms you made between the episode and 1984. We share similar ideas!