Monday, November 3, 2008

My Inspiration


After recently watching a documentary, it is clear that George Orwell’s inspiration for the novel 1984 was extracted from his surroundings. If I was to write a novel today, I would probably use the same approach. Since I spend roughly forty hours--or nearly 30% of my waking hours—a week at my high school, I would absolutely be influenced by my surroundings. Having to endure eight hours of school on a typical weekday, I cannot help but to feel as if I am captured in some sort of microcosm; the way people function and communicate around me replicates society on a smaller scale. Within a body of about one thousand people, government, factions, and social “classes” have all been formed. Clearly, if students were not forced to be bounded inside the Pascack Valley walls none of this would be possible.

My inspiration for a novel would be derived from those observations. What if groups of people from different countries are forced to live together in some sort of remote island or cell? This may sound like some sort of reality show but my novel would take this to a whole new level. When forced to cooperate, these people would have to find ways to thrive off of each other and take advantage of their surroundings to be successful in surviving. They would find themselves creating a government and perhaps unique ways of communication such as teenagers have done in my high school (ie: internet slang). Naming characters would be a breeze in this novel; I would simply use the names of my peers or my teachers. By using these ideas, I would be able to take something very commonplace to me and turn it into abstraction through creativity.

Sunday, November 2, 2008

Enemy of the State


The movie Enemy of the State directly references the novel 1984 by George Orwell and modern issues. In the scenes watched, one of the main characters makes an amazing discovery that is similar to one Winston made in 1984. On the news, several anchors claim that a local congressman has died because of a heart attack. However, by examining videotape, a man finds out that he was actually murdered! This is very similar to when Winston was sitting in the Chestnut Tree Café and sees three revolutionists sitting next to him; when the government falsely reports on their whereabouts, Winston immediately can prove to himself that the government is lying. Another similarity between the film and the novel is the presence of a dictator in both societies. In 1984, the dictator is Big brother and in Enemy of the State, the dictator is a man named Sam Albert.

The movie Enemy of the State brings up the controversial issue of phone tapping. In today’s society, people consider this to be a major issue. After the terrorist attacks in America on September 11th, 2001, the United States government implemented a system that would allow officials to listen to any conversation over a telephone. It is claimed that only suspicious calls would be monitored and the system was put forth to increase national security. I believe that this system is intrusive and ineffective despite what the government claims. Members of my family have firsthand experienced their phone lines being tapped and they are far from what the government is looking for. Even if the government was to successfully tap a conversation of a known terrorist, it is unlikely that any key information would be given over the phone.

1984: Film vs. Novel


After watching the end of the film 1984, I believe more justice is given to the novel 1984, by George Orwell, than it deserves. Many aspects of the film reflect the novel directly such as the word-for-word similarities between the script and the text. However, I thought that the film went above and beyond and took the intensity of the story to the next level. For instance, after Winston is released from the grip of the Ministry of Love, he is forced to confess to crimes he did not commit in front of the entire city. Also, in the novel, he is shown as a “cured” towards the end but several elements suggest that he is not in the movie; he does not finish his thoughts when writing on the table and it is unclear whether Winston is addressing Big Brother or Julia when he says, “I love you”.

The portrayal of Winston’s torture seems to have been intensified when translated from the novel into the movie. This is perhaps visuals are almost always more disturbing than words. For example, when Winston is being stretched on the bed, it is easier for one “feel” his pain if one can actually see it. It generally agreed that Winston’s next level of torture in Room 101 is anticlimactic in the novel. In the preceding chapters, suspension is built up suggesting that there would be something absolutely terrible in the room but it ended up only being rats. However, the film makes this scene less disappointing. When Winston is strapped onto the chair face to face with the foul rodents, I found myself cringing at the sight of the animals. Overall, the movie takes many of the novel’s scenes a step further by making them much more graphic and sometimes more meaningful than Orwell intended them to be.

V for Vendetta


The movie V for Vendetta has many relationships to my perception of Oceania in the novel 1984 by George Orwell. One of the main aspects of society in the film is its destroyed state. Blacks, browns, and yellows overwhelm the screen and in turn, a dark and depressed feel is created. A large portion of the scenes viewed also take in darkness further emphasizing a creepy and suspicious environment. Although the setting in the movie is extreme, my picture of Oceania is even more so. I viewed the society as being much more corrupt than shown in the movie.

Many other aspects of the movie are similar to the novel. First of all, society is in a totalitarian state under the rule of a man named Chancellor. Consequently, society is dominated by strict laws such as the curfews outside and the patrolling of “Fingermen” (similar to the “Thought Police”). The government tries to create as much patriotism as possible by using the slogans “Strength Through Unity, Unity Through Strength” and “England Prevails”. Also, the government provides fabricated news and exaggerated all details to make themselves seem superior to other countries. In one case, when V set off fireworks in the city, the citizens are convinced that this was planned and intentional. Another striking similarity is the government’s jailing system. People are caught suddenly and taken away. After that, these people are beaten and tortured in a jail cell until they confess desired information. This is similar to the scene in 1984 when Winston is captured and taken to the Ministry of Love. Like V, Winston is a symbol of rebellion against the government and both have intentions on setting society straight.

Minority Report

 
Many aspects of the movie Minority Report are similar to the novel 1984 by George Orwell. First, the government has a section called the “Department of Precrime”. The government can foreshadow crime before one commits it and they have the right to arrest one ahead of time. In a sense, they can see into the future. In the clips viewed, a man had intentions of murdering his wife and before he does so, he is captured and taken away. Also, an overwhelming similarity between the two medias is the communication through televisions. In the novel, there are screens everywhere in the city from under tunnels to inside offices. This is very similar to the telescreen concept in 1984; no one can escape the government’s monitoring.

Many differences also emerge from the movie and the novel. In the novel, people are arrested because when they commit “thought crime”. This type of crime emerges when people are thinking of anything that the party declares undesirable or dangerous. In the movie, the government arrests people when they commit “precrime”. This type of government intervention occurs when people are about to commit real crimes. Therefore, the intentions of the government having access to one’s thoughts are completely different. The Party in 1984 wants control over the mind and tries to translate this into power. The government in Minority Report wants this control to benefit society and help prevent chaos and disorder.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Twilight Zone vs. 1984


The episode “The Eye of the Beholder” of The Twilight Zone shares many striking resemblances to the novel 1984 by George Orwell. The episode begins with an image of a woman named Janet Tyler with bandages on her face. Through the dialogue exchanged between her and the doctor, it is apparent that they are doing experiments on her face. The hospital spends time, money, and treatments to make her as they view “normal”. It can be inferred that ugliness in Tyler’s society is a crime when the doctor says, “You can move into a special area where people of your kind have been congregated”. In the end, it turns out that Tyler is normal looking and everyone else looks like a pig. The message of this episode is that beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

The novel 1984 tells a similar story. Winston is a pariah in Oceania’s society because he sees beyond the superficial. Winston accepts that the Party is deceiving the citizens to try and gain power and, at first, is determined to stop it. The Party finds, tortures, and converts Winston into what they believe is the norm. Similar to Janet Tyler’s scenario, Winston’s possession of seemingly unusual characteristics is considered a crime that must be acknowledged. Also, Oceania has a dictator Big Brother that is seemingly parallel to the man on the television screens in “The Eye of the Beholder”. A major difference between the two stories is the final outcome; the doctors are unsuccessful with Janet Tyler but the Party is successful with Winston. Both stories, however, show that it is only possible to prove something to oneself.