After watching the end of the film 1984, I believe more justice is given to the novel 1984, by George Orwell, than it deserves. Many aspects of the film reflect the novel directly such as the word-for-word similarities between the script and the text. However, I thought that the film went above and beyond and took the intensity of the story to the next level. For instance, after Winston is released from the grip of the Ministry of Love, he is forced to confess to crimes he did not commit in front of the entire city. Also, in the novel, he is shown as a “cured” towards the end but several elements suggest that he is not in the movie; he does not finish his thoughts when writing on the table and it is unclear whether Winston is addressing Big Brother or Julia when he says, “I love you”.
The portrayal of Winston’s torture seems to have been intensified when translated from the novel into the movie. This is perhaps visuals are almost always more disturbing than words. For example, when Winston is being stretched on the bed, it is easier for one “feel” his pain if one can actually see it. It generally agreed that Winston’s next level of torture in Room 101 is anticlimactic in the novel. In the preceding chapters, suspension is built up suggesting that there would be something absolutely terrible in the room but it ended up only being rats. However, the film makes this scene less disappointing. When Winston is strapped onto the chair face to face with the foul rodents, I found myself cringing at the sight of the animals. Overall, the movie takes many of the novel’s scenes a step further by making them much more graphic and sometimes more meaningful than Orwell intended them to be.

No comments:
Post a Comment